North American Taxidermy

Taxidermist in Carroll, Ohio

1.7(7 reviews)
(614) 832-122267 W Canal St, Carroll, OH 43112View on Yelp

Customer Reviews

1.7
out of 5
7 reviews

Based on Yelp ratings

Read reviews on Yelp

About North American Taxidermy

North American Taxidermy operates out of Carroll, Ohio, a small community in Fairfield County with quick access to Columbus via US-33. The shop has collected 7 reviews with a 1.7 average rating, which is the kind of feedback that raises questions worth addressing directly before you hand over a hard-earned trophy. Carroll sits in a region where whitetail hunting and fishing are popular, so local demand for mount work is real and ongoing. If you're considering this shop, a direct conversation about their current workload and past projects is a reasonable first step.

Services

Taxidermy

Services & Process

A shop using the name North American Taxidermy signals an intent to handle a wide variety of North American game species, from white-tailed deer and wild turkey to fish and waterfowl common to Ohio's rivers and lakes. Typical services would include shoulder mounts, full body mounts, fish mounts, and bird work. Skull cleaning and antler mounting are also standard offerings at most Ohio taxidermy shops. The broad name suggests they're open to working on whatever a hunter or angler brings through the door, rather than specializing in a single species.

Service Area

The shop serves Carroll and the surrounding Fairfield County area, with Columbus and the south Columbus suburbs within easy reach via US-33. Hunters from communities like Amanda, Sugar Grove, and nearby parts of Hocking County are also within reasonable driving distance. It's a rural location with access to some of central Ohio's better deer and turkey hunting ground.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I protect myself when using a taxidermist with mixed reviews?
Ask for photos of recent work, request references from past customers, and get a written agreement that includes the price, timeline, and a description of what's included. Paying a deposit rather than the full amount upfront is also a reasonable practice.
What kinds of animals do most Ohio taxidermists handle?
Ohio hunters and anglers most commonly bring in whitetail deer, wild turkey, Canada geese, ducks, bass, walleye, and various small game. Most full-service shops can handle all of these, and some also work with exotic or out-of-state trophies.
Is Carroll, Ohio a good area for deer hunting?
Fairfield County and the surrounding region consistently produces quality whitetail deer, with a mix of agricultural fields and wooded draws that support healthy deer populations. It's part of why local taxidermy shops see steady business from fall through early winter.
What should I ask a taxidermist before dropping off my animal?
Ask how many pieces they're currently working on, what their typical turnaround time is, and whether they use commercial forms or do custom work. Seeing finished examples of the specific type of mount you want is also a smart way to judge quality before committing.
Can I get a refund if I'm unhappy with a finished mount?
Refund policies vary by shop and are rarely formalized in writing unless you ask upfront. It's worth discussing what happens if you're not satisfied before you drop off your animal, so both parties have clear expectations from the start.
How far will most taxidermists in the Carroll, Ohio area travel to pick up a specimen?
Most small taxidermy shops don't offer pickup services and expect customers to bring their specimens in directly. If you've had a particularly large animal harvested at a remote location, it's worth calling ahead to ask if any special arrangements are possible.

Is this your business?

Claim your listing to update your info and connect with customers.

Claim This Listing

More Taxidermists

All taxidermists in Carroll, OH →All taxidermists in Ohio →Browse all states →